Key Lime To Happiness

Joy Dewing a month ago

On a recent trip to South Florida, we made it a mission to try key lime pie whenever possible and to find the best. We had some good ones, delicious ones, and some mediocre ones, and then at the last minute we found this spot on our way to the airport and decided to have one last key lime pie. Y’all… we did it. We found the best. And I mean… the most flavorful, best balance of sweet and tart, perfect ratio of graham cracker crust, silky smooth and absolutely incredible. We tried the regular Key Lime, the Guava Key Lime, and the Tropical Key Lime, which was layered with flavors of mango and pineapple, all of which were perfectly balanced. There’s some absolute craft and magic going on here. It’s worth a drive from wherever you are.

Julie Compagner 4 months ago

Hidden Gem! Best key lime pies! Tried the key lime, guava key lime, mango key lime and blueberry lemon mini pies! All were absolutely spectacular! The cookie crumb bottom is a cut above the traditional graham cracker crust and the texture of the fillings is creamy and exploding with flavor. Perfect blend of tart key lime with a touch of sweetness! Drove an hour for these pies and will do it again many times! If you are in the area a must stop! Key Lime to Happiness will not disappoint!

Dani Dyer-Manna 6 months ago

Amazing and delicious! There are so many different flavors to choose from. Since we couldn't try them all, we decided to start with four and share. We both agree that the cream pie bites are some of the most amazing pies that we've ever tried. We can't wait to go back. Counter service is fantastic, the gentleman behind the register made us laugh a few times. The owner poked her head out when I exclaimed how beautiful her shop is. If you like pie and supporting a small business that is run from the heart, this is the place for you. Well done, Lauren and family.

Alexandra 6 months ago

I tried this place for the first time the other day! So delicious!! I'm gluten free and its hard to find a decent cake anywhere. But her cakes/pies here are to die for! I got the smores and fruity pebbles. The crust is sooo buttery its amazing . I can't wait to try all the other gluten free options!

Tonya Baker a year ago

The best Key Lime pie I've ever had! EVER!! We made a quick down-and-back trip to South Florida and wanted a Key Lime pie to share for a friend's birthday. This local shop popped up in a quick Google search and boy are we glad it did! Lauren was so sweet to help us and her pies are nothing short of amazing! We got two mini pies - the Chocolate Covered Key Lime and the Triple Key Lime. The Triple is 3 layered flavors - mango key lime, guava key lime, and traditional key lime. It was so good I ran in and bought one more for the road. We'll be returning in about 6 weeks and I may just have to order some full size pies to take home. It's that good!!!